A golf bag purchase is less about finding the "best" bag in the abstract and more about correctly matching format to how you actually play. Get the format wrong and no amount of pocket organization will make the bag pleasant to use.
If you walk most rounds
A lightweight stand bag with a comfortable, well-padded dual-strap carry system should be the priority — extra pockets and capacity matter far less than shoulder comfort over 18 holes. See our golf bags equipment guide for the full stand-bag buying criteria.
If you ride or push-cart most rounds
A cart bag's larger capacity and wider, more stable base are worth the extra weight you'll never actually carry. Look for full-length club dividers so shafts don't tangle, and enough organized pockets for a rangefinder, layers, and valuables.
Don't buy for the rare exception
A golfer who walks 90% of the time but occasionally rides doesn't need a cart bag "just in case" — a stand bag works fine set on a pull cart or riding cart's bag well for those occasional rounds. Buy for how you play most of the time, not the exception.